ecosophia: (Default)
John Michael Greer ([personal profile] ecosophia) wrote2019-09-06 06:46 pm

Discursive Meditation: Phase 1

Sekhmet meditatingI mentioned here a little while back -- I think it was in the process of winding up the discussion on the Sphere of Protection -- that sometime shortly I'd be doing a comparable series of posts on the second core practice of traditional occultism. Yes, that would be discursive meditation, and I plan on spending the next several weeks going over the technique and talking about how to use it. 

Let's start, though, with a couple of details that tend to be forgotten. First of all, there's nothing particularly exotic or, ahem, Asian about meditation -- though of course most Asian spiritual traditions teach it as a matter of course. So did most Christian churches until not much more than a century ago. For a change, this isn't something that got dumped at the time of the Scientific Revolution, when so much of the Western world's spiritual heritage hit the dumpster in a hurry; this got dropped in the late 19th and very early 20th century, when most denominations discarded their remaining methods of personal spiritual practice and embraced notions of spirituality that focused on collective salvation, either by sheer faith and nothing else (the fundamentalist approach) or by charitable works (the social gospel approach). 

So we're dealing with something that used to be practiced by people all over the western world. (The word "meditation," remember, didn't have to be imported from some exotic language; it's from Latin, the normal language of educated people in the West until 1850 or so.) That's the first thing to keep in mind. The second is that what we're talking about is different in a crucial way from the kinds of meditation that were imported from Asia in the late 19th and 20th centuries. Nearly all of those latter methods focus on silencing the thinking mind; classic Western meditation doesn't. Instead, it focuses and directs the thinking mind. That's implicit in the word itself. When we say a crime was premeditated, for example, that doesn't mean that the perp chanted a mantra or practiced mindfulness meditation before doing it; it means that the perp thought it through, planned it, and deliberately decided to do it. 

Western meditation -- to give it its proper name, discursive meditation -- is focused, deliberate, reflective thought. A subject for thinking -- a theme, in the standard jargon -- serves the same role in discursive meditation as a mantra or what have you in other kinds of meditation. You focus your attention on it just as intently as on any other kind of meditation -- but that means you think about it, keep your mind and your thoughts on it, explore it, and understand it. In later posts in this series we'll talk about how that works and why it's so important.  For now, let's start with the first step, which is posture. 

Let's start with posture. No, you don't have to tie your legs into an overhand knot to practice meditation, and in fact for the kind of meditation we're doing, you don't want to do that. The posture to use is the one shown above in those fine Egyptian statues of Sekhmet the lion-goddess. Sit on a relatively hard chair; if it has a back, slide forward, so you don't touch it at all, and your spine is free. Your feet rest flat on the floor, your knees and hips are at right angles, your hands rest palm down on your thighs, your head is straight. Look forward and down, as though at something on the floor a few yards ahead of you. Breathe slowly and easily. 

(If you're already practicing the Sphere of Protection, do this in the space you've just cleared with that ritual. Set the chair in the space before you begin, and get used to doing the ritual around it. More on this later.)

Got it? Now don't move for five minutes. Don't fidget, shift, wiggle, scratch an itch or anything else. Leave your body completely still for five minutes by the clock. Do this once a day. That's your assignment for the next week. 

Unless you've already done this, or practiced certain other exercises that have the same effect, this is going to be much harder than you think. Our bodies are actually full of tensions and discomforts we never notice, and part of the constant shifting and wiggling and fidgeting that most people do most of the time is a matter of trying not to notice just how uncomfortable we are. Confront it head on. Stay still for those five minutes, no matter what. You'll still probably be having some trouble at the end of the week, but at that point we can go on and add something that will make it even worse. ;-)

That's one of the secrets of meditation. It is literally the most boring, grueling, frustrating thing you will ever do -- and once you get the hang of how to do it and why it's important, you'll do it every day, because the payoffs are worth so much more than the boredom et al. 

Five minutes a day sitting in the posture shown above. Got it?  Go for it. 
aghaveagh: (Default)

[personal profile] aghaveagh 2019-09-07 09:14 pm (UTC)(link)
I am hardworking when it comes to "thinking" (much less so with physical challenges, although I am working on improving my health with... actual weightlifting :) Funny you mentioned it.

I also love to challenge my mind and my gut reactions constantly. This is why your post got me intrigued right away. Willing to try your method because... why not? I have never meditated before. Willing to thrust the process and its long term results.

Side note: I had never heard of you and druidry until a few days ago. The entire thing actively captured my attention non-stop since I saw your name mentioned on twitter.
aghaveagh: (Default)

[personal profile] aghaveagh 2019-09-08 11:54 pm (UTC)(link)
Someone mentioned your name as the "most interesting living man in the world" (this tweet here: https://twitter.com/BeigeShiba/status/1168225939647393792 )

I got curious who you were based on this mention. I ordered 2 of your books as a result, and found this blog a few days later!

(Anonymous) 2019-09-09 01:18 pm (UTC)(link)
As it turns out, I heard about you from another person whose alias is a dog. In this case, Borzoi. He was very influenced by your books "Decline & Fall" and "Dark Age America".

Though my personal favourite is "The Ecotechnic Future". Even though it is rather more dry and technical in tone, I find that its ultimate message is a lot more hopeful and I encourage people to read it first, on that basis.

I also like sharing the video of the CFPUP roundtable you participated in. You get some really good points in there, though the whole thing was a very high quality discussion.

social media

(Anonymous) 2019-09-09 01:20 pm (UTC)(link)
There are also over 100 Instagram posts hashtagged with your name, usually when people are reading and posting a photo of your books, but sometimes promoting podcasts and one person even did a great charcoal drawing of you!

[personal profile] mhop 2019-09-09 10:25 pm (UTC)(link)
it seems #ecosophia is quite active on twitter, just now sorted to "latest" I see someone has posted a call for a Williamson/Greer 2020 ticket... :) commentary on that could be interesting... There is also appears to be an [profile] archdruidreport account subtitled "The unofficial channeling of John Michael Greer's Blog".

There is a swirling in the twitter-verse it seems...
aghaveagh: (Default)

[personal profile] aghaveagh 2019-09-10 09:35 pm (UTC)(link)
re: marcus, done