Personally, I would recommend The Troth -- in addition to having a significant real world presence, their lore program and courses are excellent. Also, the AFA's Declaration of Purpose groups all white people together as if part of a single monoculture ("All native religions spring from the unique collective soul of a particular race."), not taking into account particular groups of people like Slavs and Celts whose cultures were not the same as the Germanic or Norse.
Re: Asatru Folk Assembly